Financial Islam - Islamic Finance
  • Home
  • News
  • The Islamic law
    • Socio-economic Justice
    • The ownership of wealth
    • Prohibition of Riba, Maysir and Gharar
    • Zakah
  • Islamic Economics
    • Shareholding in Islam
    • Loans and debts in the Sharia'h
    • The Islamic Development Bank
  • Islamic Finance
    • Financial intermediation
    • Islamic accounting
    • Financial statements analysis
    • Regulation and Supervision
      • Shari’ah Boards
      • Operations within the conventional system
    • Islamic Commercial contracts
      • Relationship with central banks
      • Valid transactions
      • Mudarabah
      • Musharakah
      • Diminishing Musharakah
      • Murabahah
      • Salam
      • Istisna'a
      • Ijarah
      • Wakalah
      • Other contracts
  • Islamic Banking Operations
    • Starting an Islamic Bank
    • Commercial transactions
    • Deposits
    • Islamic credit cards
    • Fee-based services
    • Letter of Credit
    • Bank Guarantee
    • Modes of financing and investment
      • Ijarah financing
      • Musharakah and Mudarabah certificates
      • Diminishing Musharakah
      • Replacing interest-based lending
    • Capital Market Operations
      • Islamic Unit Trusts
      • Islamic Fund Structures
      • Investment screening
      • Islamic Market Indexes
      • Islamic ETF
      • Venture Capital
      • Foreign exchange
  • Sukuk
    • Sukuk structures
    • Controversy
    • Indexation of financial obligations
    • Risks underlying Sukuk
  • Takaful
    • Takaful Agreements
    • Takaful models
    • Areas of Takaful
    • General insurance
    • Life insurance
    • Reinsurance
    • Corporate Governance
  • Video Zone
  • Events Agenda 2016
    • Events Agenda 2015
    • Events Agenda 2014
    • Events Agenda 2013
    • Events Agenda 2012
    • Events Agenda 2011
    • Events Agenda 2010
  • Glossary
  • Contact
  • 404
  • Home
  • News
  • The Islamic law
    • Socio-economic Justice
    • The ownership of wealth
    • Prohibition of Riba, Maysir and Gharar
    • Zakah
  • Islamic Economics
    • Shareholding in Islam
    • Loans and debts in the Sharia'h
    • The Islamic Development Bank
  • Islamic Finance
    • Financial intermediation
    • Islamic accounting
    • Financial statements analysis
    • Regulation and Supervision
      • Shari’ah Boards
      • Operations within the conventional system
    • Islamic Commercial contracts
      • Relationship with central banks
      • Valid transactions
      • Mudarabah
      • Musharakah
      • Diminishing Musharakah
      • Murabahah
      • Salam
      • Istisna'a
      • Ijarah
      • Wakalah
      • Other contracts
  • Islamic Banking Operations
    • Starting an Islamic Bank
    • Commercial transactions
    • Deposits
    • Islamic credit cards
    • Fee-based services
    • Letter of Credit
    • Bank Guarantee
    • Modes of financing and investment
      • Ijarah financing
      • Musharakah and Mudarabah certificates
      • Diminishing Musharakah
      • Replacing interest-based lending
    • Capital Market Operations
      • Islamic Unit Trusts
      • Islamic Fund Structures
      • Investment screening
      • Islamic Market Indexes
      • Islamic ETF
      • Venture Capital
      • Foreign exchange
  • Sukuk
    • Sukuk structures
    • Controversy
    • Indexation of financial obligations
    • Risks underlying Sukuk
  • Takaful
    • Takaful Agreements
    • Takaful models
    • Areas of Takaful
    • General insurance
    • Life insurance
    • Reinsurance
    • Corporate Governance
  • Video Zone
  • Events Agenda 2016
    • Events Agenda 2015
    • Events Agenda 2014
    • Events Agenda 2013
    • Events Agenda 2012
    • Events Agenda 2011
    • Events Agenda 2010
  • Glossary
  • Contact
  • 404

Islamic finance outsources scholars' supervision to grow

11/3/2010

1 Comment

 
Picture
Bankers in Islamic finance are increasingly outsourcing sharia supervision due to a lack of scholars in the industry, but critics say this is making the sector even less transparent and slowing its development.

The $1 trillion industry rode a five-year oil boom until the 2008 property crash in the Gulf Arab region raised complaints that many of its investment instruments can be seen as mere copy-cats of conventional banking products, threatening the sector's future growth.

Critics say growth and product innovation is being further stifled by the limited number of top scholars available to join the sharia boards of Islamic banks, some sitting on up to 80 boards.

"In banking you can lose a deal in one day," said John Sandwick, a Geneva-based Islamic wealth and asset manager.

"If the scholars are not responsive, and we know it is literally impossible for one man to provide so much work, then everyone suffers," he said.

Instead of maintaining their own costly sharia boards with prominent scholars, bankers are increasingly using consultancy firms that directly deal with the scholars.

"Instead of worrying about processing time with a few busy scholars, you get a professional team available to process your needs in real time," said Sandwick.

RUBBERSTAMP

During the boom years, scholars in the Gulf Arab region allowed investment firms to book large amounts of up-front fees on the money they raised for property deals, violating the Islamic principle that risk and rewards should be shared.

Critics say sharia consultancy firms will not bring about any real sharia supervision.

"They will have one or two people in their organisation to structure the product and then will just rubberstamp it from three or four scholars and pay them a fee and get it done for you," said Aly Khorshid, a scholar and sharia consultant based in the United Kingdom.

"Of course (outsourcing) is growing because they're going to the institutions and say give me x amount, I will get you a structure, a fatwa, a board, in no time," he said.

Bahrain-based industry body AAOIFI is drafting rules to regulate sharia scholars' shareholdings and the number of sharia supervisory boards a single scholar can sit on.

Khorshid said that the number of boards scholars can sit on should be limited to just one.

Currently, sharia boards only act as advisers and are not accountable for decisions as boards of directors would be.

"If you had the sharia board responsible and accountable for what's happening, then I don't think one person would engage in too many," said Khorshid.

Regulators such as the Islamic Financial Services Board (IFSB), an association of Islamic finance regulators, also seem to be wary of sharia outsourcing.

"In recent years there has been an increasing trend towards the formation of sharia advisory firms which offer services such as sharia audit/review, although they can not be considered as an alternative to a proper full-panel sharia board," it says in its standard on sharia supervision.

Murat Unal, chief executive of consultancy Funds@Work that has researched the issue of sharia scholars, said that the problem was further compounded by the fact that sharia scholars also sit on the boards of standard setters like AAOIFI.

"They will certainly kick off reforms, but they won't be as comprehensive as you would possibly wish for, because they will make sure not to step on each others' feet," he said.

He said one practical step would be to convince bankers and scholars to only have one top scholar on each board rather than three or four prominent ones, allowing a greater number of junior scholars to join boards.

source: Reuters

1 Comment
San Elizario webcams link
9/9/2012 03:32:01 am

Just dropped by to say hello, so, hello mate!

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    /news.htmlPicture

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.
Photos used under Creative Commons from Ranoush., MUSHU", Dave_B_, Open.Michigan
  • Home
  • News
  • The Islamic law
    • Socio-economic Justice
    • The ownership of wealth
    • Prohibition of Riba, Maysir and Gharar
    • Zakah
  • Islamic Economics
    • Shareholding in Islam
    • Loans and debts in the Sharia'h
    • The Islamic Development Bank
  • Islamic Finance
    • Financial intermediation
    • Islamic accounting
    • Financial statements analysis
    • Regulation and Supervision
      • Shari’ah Boards
      • Operations within the conventional system
    • Islamic Commercial contracts
      • Relationship with central banks
      • Valid transactions
      • Mudarabah
      • Musharakah
      • Diminishing Musharakah
      • Murabahah
      • Salam
      • Istisna'a
      • Ijarah
      • Wakalah
      • Other contracts
  • Islamic Banking Operations
    • Starting an Islamic Bank
    • Commercial transactions
    • Deposits
    • Islamic credit cards
    • Fee-based services
    • Letter of Credit
    • Bank Guarantee
    • Modes of financing and investment
      • Ijarah financing
      • Musharakah and Mudarabah certificates
      • Diminishing Musharakah
      • Replacing interest-based lending
    • Capital Market Operations
      • Islamic Unit Trusts
      • Islamic Fund Structures
      • Investment screening
      • Islamic Market Indexes
      • Islamic ETF
      • Venture Capital
      • Foreign exchange
  • Sukuk
    • Sukuk structures
    • Controversy
    • Indexation of financial obligations
    • Risks underlying Sukuk
  • Takaful
    • Takaful Agreements
    • Takaful models
    • Areas of Takaful
    • General insurance
    • Life insurance
    • Reinsurance
    • Corporate Governance
  • Video Zone
  • Events Agenda 2016
    • Events Agenda 2015
    • Events Agenda 2014
    • Events Agenda 2013
    • Events Agenda 2012
    • Events Agenda 2011
    • Events Agenda 2010
  • Glossary
  • Contact
  • 404